JAGDISH RATTANANI AND T JACOB JOHN
The world’s second largest market for vaccines is India. The world’s largest vaccine producer (the Pune-based Serum Institute of India) is in India. This should be a simple case of, ‘ergo, problem solved!’ But we have turned this on its head. It is plain that we don’t have enough vaccines. Citizens mill about in long lines, standing hours to get protected from a disease many will contract given the conditions in which they wait. Many must take their chances another day because the vaccines run out. All this in the midst of a deadly second wave that has taken new infections to over 4,00,000 a day and deaths to 3,500 a day, on an official count alone. We have been reduced to begging the world for help.
Even if we take the missteps that led us to the misery of the second wave in our stride, the missteps on the vaccines are a new order of failure. The planning, pricing and actual rollout are nothing short of a callous and culpable act for which the ordinary people of India will pay a terrible price – in money spent, in lives lost and in terms of signalling the pharma giants of the world that India has become a place to make money even in the midst of untold misery. What then will the rest of the world do but pounce in, and extract a pound of flesh from a nation that has a long and illustrious history of keeping prices of medicines and vaccines in check?
Barely four years ago, the government of India under Narendra Modi stood up to a very strong effort from stent manufacturers and powerful trade lobbies to impose price control on stents, which were being sold at an exorbitant rate in India. Prices were force-dropped 80 per cent in some cases with the intention of making advanced cardiac care affordable for a wider section of the population. Trade and the pharma business cried foul, issuing dire warnings of how the big companies will stop selling advanced stents in India and how patients would lose out but none of this happened. Private hospitals did, however, raise their costs to make up on lost margins, one more indicator that the private sector in health is failing the nation.
Why then would such a government allow the Serum Institute of India, which makes the AstraZeneca-Oxford vaccine called ‘Covishield’, a juicy money-making deal on a direly-needed vaccine in the midst of a crisis? What is the secret behind this pact that will generate Rs 60,000 crore in revenue, if one is to count just 50 crore people (roughly 40 per cent of Indians) taking two doses each at Rs 600 per dose in the private sector alone? Would this not be a case of usurious profits when even at Rs 150 a shot charged to the Union government, the company admittedly made money? Why then charge four times when the people of India are dying all around us? Similar questions can be asked of the other Indian vaccine manufacturer, the Hyderabad-based Bharat Biotech International, the manufacturer of the indigenous vaccine named ‘Covaxin’.
Further, what is the difference between the Union government and the state governments in so far as vaccination for citizens is concerned, with the former paying Rs 150 but the latter being charged a higher price of Rs 400 per dose? After a hue and cry, this price then was reduced to Rs 300 per dose for the states, a drop of 25 per cent “as a philanthropic gesture” that “will…save countless lives,” as the CEO of the Serum Institute of India Adar Poonawalla put it. Isn’t that an admission in some sense that vaccine manufacturers have been allowed to profiteer in so blatant a manner that philanthropy is being invoked to save lives? Bharat Biotech followed suit, reducing the price of its vaccine to the states from Rs 600 to Rs 400 a dose.
Both companies are private sector entities entitled to their profits. They are also at the forefront of the war against COVID-19. A pandemic response demands that vaccination coverage be universal and free. With numbers of doses known, orders could have been placed in advance. But the government did none of this. In the initial days, it paid almost nothing to the companies to support or ramp up production. It has instead now set the stage for public-private sector mismatches that will occur when a differential pricing system is used. Expect the free provider vaccine stations to dry up soon.
The central government under normal circumstances must advise states to pay no more than it is paying, and negotiate with the suppliers for a bulk order with the Centre-state cost-sharing to be decided as policy. Is it at all possible for a state authority to pay more for any set of goods and services that are bought in bulk at a price negotiated by the Centre, that too in an emergency?
This column will not go into the sudden departure of Adar Poonawalla for Britain over the weekend in the midst of the crisis and his statements to the press there. There is likely more here than we know or Poonawalla is willing to tell us just yet. It is a pointer to just how much the issue of vaccines has been messed up, a mirror to the underhand nature of the dealings, and to the hubris, callousness and dressing-up that has been the hallmark of the government’s response to the pandemic.
Consider that on April 19, the Prime Minister announced a “liberalised and accelerated phase 3 strategy” of vaccination effective May 1 that brought in a public-private distinction in vaccination. Within two days, on April 21, Serum Institute announced differential pricing for states and the private sector, keeping silent on prices for the Centre. On April 22, Dr Krishna M Ella, the founder-chairman and MD of Bharat Biotech reportedly said that he would “like to get the maximum price…to recover all costs…”
Poonawalla is known for his high-flying ways. Dr Ella is known for his simple living. Both have now begun talking a language of profit maximisation in the midst of a crisis where bodies are lined up in crematoriums across India. This is quite a change from the vision of the founder of Serum Institute Dr Cyrus Poonawalla, the current CEO’s father, who has often stressed sacrificing profits to make vaccines affordable. Worse, the current pricing games are about a vaccine that has not yet been licensed, and is only approved for “restricted use in an emergency situation” (for Covishield) and for “restricted use under clinical trial mode” (for Covaxin). Because of this licensing condition, these vaccines technically cannot be sold, at least not yet.
It may be futile to look to the vaccine makers for answers when the government of the day is mired in games and projections, not facts and solutions. It would have been possible to have both the vaccine makers, Serum Institute and Bharat Biotech, stand tall and write a story of grit and growth; to be affordable and profitable. If they didn’t play along, compulsory licensing was always a reasonable and legitimate way out for the government. We could have said when the time came, we stood together and tall. Alas, we were all pulled down.
(Jagdish Rattanani has also contributed to the article. Rattanani is a journalist and faculty member at SPJIMR). Billion Press