Arnav Das Sharma
It took roughly 70 years for the first edition of the Oxford Dictionary to be assembled, and those years saw the meeting of two men who, on the face of it, looked quite similar, but had lived vastly different lives. The story of these two men — James Murray and Dr William Chester Minor — are intertwined with the history of the OED, and together tell a compelling story of scholarship, violence, madness, poverty, and an indelible love for words and their history.
On May 10, the story of these two men will play out on the silver screen, in a film titled ‘The Professor and the Madman’, starring Mel Gibson and Sean Penn. The movie is an adaptation of the 1998 bestselling book, ‘The Surgeon of Crowthorne’, by journalist Simon Winchester.
Birth of the OED
It is difficult to imagine today that until the 19th century, English did not have a complete dictionary. The only one existing till then was the 1755 dictionary compiled and edited by Samuel Johnson. In November 1857, the members of the London Philological Society sat down to hear a paper by the Dean of Westminster, Richard Trench. Trench argued that the English system of preserving words was so inadequate that the task needed to be taken up from scratch; that what Britain needed more than ever was a worthy successor to Johnson’s dictionary. This speech gave birth to the Oxford Dictionary.
But things took a drastic turn from here on. The first editor of the project died unexpectedly, and the second devoted most of his time to frequenting the red light districts of Victorian England, debating socialism and cycling, rather than working on the dictionary itself. The project truly started when a little-known school teacher and philologist, James Murray, took over as editor. His first task was to advertise in all the leading newspapers of the day that the project was looking for ‘volunteers’ in the English-speaking world to send him quotations which would show how the meanings of words had changed over time.
It was this that brought William Chester Minor onto the scene. An American who fought in the Civil War, Minor was an army surgeon. But while in the army, he was tasked with branding an Irish solder in the Union Army on the face with the letter ‘D’ for ‘Deserter’. Winchester argues that similar harsh conditions in the army and the violence of the Civil War may have played a part in Minor developing a case of severe dementia and paranoia. After the War, Minor emigrated to London, looking for a better climate to help his dementia. But an incident there would seal his fate.
One of the notorious, crime-infested areas in Victorian London was a place called Lambeth Marsh. A place rife with thieves, pimps and prostitutes. Here, Minor — known to frequent red light districts — haunted by severe paranoia, shot a passerby named George Merrett, believing the man to be a thief when in reality he was just a working-class man.
Minor was arrested and sent to Broadmoor, the infamous mental asylum at Crowthorne. But sustained by his army pension and good conduct, he received better treatment, a room, and was allowed to buy books. It was through this correspondence with booksellers that Minor got to know of Murray’s advertisement, and culling from his vast reading at the asylum, began to send to Murray quotations. These papers Minor would send Murray every week, for over 20 years.
In fact when Murray finally met Minor in 1891, in his asylum cell, the former realised that without Minor’s contribution, the OED would have had over four centuries of word-origins missing from its roster. Many words that Minor rescued came from his eccentric reading choices. Books of political philosophy gave him etymologies of words now used frequently, like ‘countenance’. From his reading of travel literature, particularly about India — Minor was born in Sri Lanka — he gave to the OED words like ‘guz’, which is basically an Indian measure of length.
Yet despite his good conduct, the authorities refused to let Minor out of Broadmoor. As the 1800s drew to a close, James Murray sent dozens of letters to the government, and personally petitioned leading officers of the law to let Minor go, arguing that a mental asylum was no place for a man of his calibre.
Only in 1910 did Murray’s petitions succeed, when one reached a young home secretary with a penchant for cigars and whiskey, a man named Winston Churchill. Minor was let go and died at his home in 1922.
When we turn the pages of the OED, it is impossible to notice the different threads of history that seem to bind it together. And residing somewhere in between the pages are still the echoes of these two remarkable men, a professor and a madman.